
You do not need to prove misconduct before raising a concern, but you do need a specific, good-faith account and a channel able to assess it without widening harm.
Know what you are reporting
A surprising result, poor supervision or a methodological disagreement is not automatically misconduct. In US Public Health Service research, the federal definition in 42 CFR Part 93 covers fabrication, falsification or plagiarism in proposing, performing, reviewing or reporting research. A finding requires a significant departure from accepted practices of the relevant research community, misconduct committed intentionally, knowingly or recklessly, and proof by a preponderance of the evidence. Honest error and differences of opinion are not research misconduct.
Other countries and institutions use broader definitions. The policy governing the work—not a general internet definition—determines jurisdiction. Your role is not to reach the finding. It is to report a concern in good faith with enough specificity for an authorised office to assess it.
Separate three levels:
| Level | Example | First route |
|---|---|---|
| Scientific question | A result cannot be reproduced; a method is unclear | Ask through normal research or editorial discussion if safe |
| Policy concern | Missing records, undisclosed deviation, questionable authorship or repeated poor practice | Seek confidential advice from integrity, compliance or ombuds staff |
| Possible misconduct | Data appear invented, altered to mislead or copied without attribution | Use the formal research-misconduct reporting channel |
If there is an immediate risk to a patient, participant, animal, worker or the public, contact the responsible safety authority now. A misconduct process can run in parallel; it should not delay protective action.
For a broad account of definitions and institutional roles, see research integrity in medical publishing. This guide focuses on the reporter’s safe first steps.
Write an observation-based chronology
Start a contemporaneous note. Record dates, systems, versions and exact statements. Separate what you personally saw from what another person told you and from what you infer.
Weak: “The principal investigator fabricated the western blot.”
Assessable: “On 14 September I opened the authorised project folder and compared Figure 3b in manuscript version 12 with raw image files WB_044 and WB_061. The figure lanes appear in a different order, and I could not find a file showing the assembled image. On 15 September I asked where the assembly record was stored; the response was that no record was needed. I have not determined whether an explanation exists.”
Use a simple evidence schedule:
| Item | Record |
|---|---|
| Output at issue | Manuscript number, DOI, grant, thesis, dataset, figure or table |
| Observation | What you directly saw or heard |
| Date and context | When, where and in what authorised role |
| Source location | System or custodian holding the original |
| Corroboration | A record or person who can independently verify it |
| Uncertainty | Alternative explanation or information you do not have |
Do not improve the evidence. Never edit a file to highlight a suspected alteration, change metadata, test someone’s password, search accounts without authority or remove an original from its system. Do not email participant data to yourself. Tell the integrity officer where protected records are held so authorised staff can preserve them with access controls and an audit trail.
Choose the right confidential channel
Read the institution’s misconduct policy and funder terms. Look for the research integrity officer, designated institutional official, compliance office or equivalent. In the United States, the Office of Research Integrity oversees institutional handling for research supported by the Public Health Service and provides information about making allegations. Other funders and regulators have their own routes.
The respondent’s supervisor is not always the safest first recipient. They may have a conflict, lack authority to preserve records, or attempt an informal resolution that alerts people before evidence is secured. Ask the designated office:
- Does this office have jurisdiction over the work and people?
- Can I seek advice before making a formal allegation?
- What confidentiality can the process provide, and what are its limits?
- How are relevant records preserved?
- Which anti-retaliation policy and contact apply?
- Will I receive acknowledgement and a case reference?
If the concern involves the integrity officer or senior institutional leadership, use the alternate named in policy, a funder or regulator with jurisdiction, or independent advice. Journals can assess and correct publications but usually cannot investigate employment records or laboratory conduct. COPE’s guidance on cooperation between research institutions and journals describes those separate roles.
Plan safety, confidentiality and support
No process can promise perfect anonymity. Details may identify the source, and procedural fairness may require the respondent to understand the substance of an allegation. Ask what “confidential” means before providing identifying information: who receives it, what is recorded, when disclosure is required, and whether anonymous intake is possible.
Make a support plan before reporting when power differences are severe. Possible independent resources include an ombuds office, union representative, professional association, employee-assistance service or lawyer familiar with local employment and whistleblower law. For PHS-supported research, 42 CFR 93.300 requires institutions to take all reasonable and practical steps to protect the positions and reputations of good-faith complainants and witnesses and to protect them from retaliation. This article is not legal advice; protections and deadlines vary by jurisdiction.
Document your normal work lawfully: objectives, completed tasks, feedback, schedule changes and authorship discussions. Do not secretly record conversations unless you know it is lawful and permitted. If an adverse action occurs, note the date, decision-maker, stated reason and comparable prior practice, then report it through the anti-retaliation channel. A research-integrity assessment and a retaliation complaint may be separate processes.
Limit disclosure. Posting allegations online, copying an entire department or contacting the media can harm innocent co-authors, breach confidentiality and complicate an investigation. Share only with people who need to advise, protect or assess.
Send a specific, contained report
A useful report is short enough to understand and detailed enough to route. Include:
- Your contact details, or a statement that you are using an anonymous channel.
- The person, project and output concerned.
- A dated chronology of direct observations.
- The possible policy category, framed as a concern rather than a finding.
- Exact locations of records and any immediate preservation risk.
- Any urgent safety or publication deadline.
- Conflicts that could affect who handles the report.
- A request for acknowledgement, case reference and next steps.
Model opening:
I am reporting a good-faith concern about possible falsification in Figure 3 of manuscript MED-2026-184. I am not asking the office to accept my interpretation without assessment. The attached chronology identifies the image versions I accessed in my authorised role, the differences I observed and the storage locations of the originals. The manuscript is currently under review, and the shared account is scheduled for closure on 30 October. Please confirm receipt, advise whether preservation action is needed, and tell me the applicable confidentiality and anti-retaliation process.
Send copies, not originals, only where you are authorised to do so. Redact unrelated personal or participant information where the receiving office agrees. Keep the original submission, acknowledgement and case reference in a secure location permitted by policy.
Our research integrity office checklist shows what should happen on the receiving side: conflict checks, scope, interim risk and preservation before wider notification.
What happens after intake
Terminology varies, but many systems begin with assessment to determine jurisdiction and whether the allegation is sufficiently credible and specific. A formal inquiry may decide whether a full investigation is warranted. An investigation then examines records, interviews relevant people and applies the required standard.
You may be asked for clarification or an interview. Answer the question asked, distinguish memory from records and correct mistakes promptly. Do not conduct parallel interviews or recruit colleagues to a side. Investigators need independent accounts, not a group narrative assembled beforehand.
The office may be unable to tell you details about personnel action or the final outcome. Ask what status information policy allows and how concerns affecting a submitted or published article will be communicated. If a journal needs to hold a manuscript or correct the record, the institution and journal should coordinate without assuming each can perform the other’s role.
Use this follow-up checklist:
- Receipt and case reference recorded
- Urgent safety and evidence-preservation risks acknowledged
- Handler conflicts disclosed
- Confidentiality limits understood
- Clarification requests answered from records
- Retaliation concerns reported through the named route
- Escalation or review options checked if the matter is closed without explanation
Avoid the actions that create new harm
In short: no confrontation to extract an admission, no edits to source files and no inference presented as proof. Do not warn the people involved, even to tell them to keep their records; let authorised staff preserve records before notice under the applicable process. Do not expand one concern into claims about an entire career without evidence.
Also avoid silence when the risk is immediate. A good-faith report can be mistaken and still be appropriate. The standard for raising a concern is not the standard for making a misconduct finding.
Safely reporting suspected research misconduct means keeping the report accurate, contained and capable of fair assessment. State what you observed, identify where the records are, use the authorised channel, understand confidentiality limits and get independent support when the power imbalance makes that necessary.
Frequently asked questions
Do I need proof before I report suspected research misconduct?
You do not need to prove a finding, because investigation belongs to the authorised institution or agency. You should have a good-faith basis and describe specific observations, records or inconsistencies rather than rumour. The receiving office assesses whether the concern falls within its policy and whether further inquiry is warranted.
Should I confront the researcher before reporting a concern?
Not automatically. A question about an apparent calculation error may be resolved through normal scientific discussion, but confrontation can risk evidence, confidentiality, participant safety or your own position. If fabrication, falsification, plagiarism, coercion or retaliation is plausible, seek confidential advice from the research integrity or ombuds office first.
Can I report research misconduct anonymously?
Some channels accept anonymous concerns, but policies differ. Anonymous reporting can limit follow-up questions, and details in the report may still identify you. Ask the receiving channel what confidentiality it can provide, what records are created and under what circumstances information must be disclosed.
What evidence should I include in a misconduct report?
Include a dated chronology, the exact output or record at issue, identifiers such as DOI, grant or figure number, what you personally observed, and where authorised originals are held. Distinguish facts from inference. Do not take records you are not entitled to access, alter metadata, secretly access accounts or circulate confidential participant information.
What should I do if I fear retaliation after reporting?
Before reporting, contact an ombuds office, union, professional association or independent legal adviser where appropriate, and review the institution's anti-retaliation process. Keep lawful contemporaneous notes of work decisions and communications. Report any adverse action promptly through the named channel rather than assuming the misconduct case automatically covers retaliation.